Saturday, June 25 2016

Alibhai-Brown views victory of female Muslim MPs over 'reactionary Islam'

 Yasmin Alibhai-Brown dissects the election results in her column in today’s Independent.

Assessing the correlation between national sentiment and election outcomes Alibhai-Brown comments on the banishing of the BNP, the ethnic and gender make up of the new parliament and the country’s decision to punish Labour while denying the Tories a firm mandate to govern unilaterally. Not surprising she should take aim at her favourite bugbear, Muslims, in appraising the election of the three new female Muslim Labour MPs; Shabana Mahmood, Rushanara Ali and Yasmin Qureishi.

She writes:

‘The number of black and Asian MPs went up from 14 to 27. Six Asian women were elected and three were Muslims. Rushanara Ali, whose parents are Bangladeshi immigrants, won in Bethnal Green and Bow, thus crushing the organised misogyny of many local Muslim men. Shabana Mahmood replaces Clare Short in Ladywood Birmingham. Both these women were local girls who got to Oxbridge. Barrister Yasmin Qureshi won in Bolton South-East, not an easy place. Here, reactionary Islam and social conservatism dominate and she must have had a hard time. Clever, ambitious, their hair flowing with defiance, these candidates have made history.’

Only Alibhai-Brown would reduce the achievements of these women in getting elected to a simple binary of enlightened Muslim women gaining over obscurantist Muslim men. As if the election of these Muslim women owed nothing to the support their campaigns have received from both Muslim men and women in their constituencies. Hustings organized by ENGAGE have been well attended by both men and women. Were she less occupied with peddling the usual stereotypes on gender relations in Islam, Alibhai-Brown might usefully find that the achievements of the three new Muslim female Labour MPs owes much to the efforts of local Muslims and others determined to support the candidate of their choice. Only in Alibhai-Brown’s analysis would the electoral outcome be reduced to something as superfluous as the uncovered heads of Muslim females.

Last Updated on Monday, 07 June 2010 12:01


0 #4 Where is the proof?Puzzled 2010-05-20 14:24
" looser immigration rules so their sons can import Muslim wives from the village,"
Quote | Report to administrator
0 #3 MrFrancis Wilson 2010-05-18 21:19
Seems to me that British Muslims have forgotten Labour's sins in launching the invasion of Iraq and allowing Israel a free hand in Lebanon by allowing excellent Respect candidates such as George Galloway and especially Salma Yaqoob to lose to Labour ... and all because Labour promised them better social benefits, looser immigration rules so their sons can import Muslim wives from the village, and higher carer allowances ... I'm sorry to say that British Muslims have voted with their wallets not their hearts ... shame!
Quote | Report to administrator
0 #2 Ab 2010-05-18 07:17
"Rushanara Ali, whose parents are Bangladeshi immigrants, won in Bethnal Green and Bow, thus crushing the organised misogyny of many local Muslim men."

Please do not play this game...this is childish writing from a report! A winner of an election is a winner. Labour could have put anyone up and they would have won in that area.
Quote | Report to administrator
0 #1 not representedgus 2010-05-15 20:10
Muslims are still underrepresented.

Here are the current jewish mps
John Bercow
Jonathan Djanogly
Michael Ellis
Michael Fabricant
Robert Halfon
Richard Harrington
Oliver Letwin
Julian Lewis
Brooks Newmark
Sir Malcolm Rifkind
Lee Scott
Grant Shapps

Lynne Featherstone
Julian Huppert

David Miliband
Ed Miliband
Luciana Berger
Louise Ellman
Ivan Lewis
Fabian Hamilton
Margaret Hodge
Sir Gerald Kaufman
David Winnick

Supporters of Israel across the political divide will be comforted by the election of Luciana Berger, director of Labour Friends of Israel; Richard Harrington, Executive Chair of Conservative Friends of Israel; and CFI's political director Robert Halfon.
Quote | Report to administrator

This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
If you are experiencing problems please contact

Engage Publications

Books of Interest